Control of ductile fracture propagation in modern gas pipelines

Authors

  • V. S. Vakhrusheva State Higher Education Establishment “Pridniprovsk State Academy of Civil Engineering and Architecture”, Ukraine https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2663-2714
  • A. D. Luchkov State Enterprise “Research and Dsign-technology Institute of the Tube Industry Ya.Yu. Osada by name”, Ukraine
  • M. V. Pushkarenko State Higher Education Establishment “Pridniprovsk State Academy of Civil Engineering and Architecture”, Ukraine https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6253-8637

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.30838/J.PMHTM.2413.260319.19.297

Keywords:

running ductile fracture arrest, full scale burst test, gas pipeline, Batelle Two Curv Method (BTCM), Drop Weight Tear Test (DWTT), Charpy-V energy, DWTT energy, equations of correlation, grade X65, X70, X80, absorbed energy

Abstract

Problem statement. The control of destruction  expansion is important aspect of exploitation safety supporting of the modern high-pressure gas pipelines. The technology of such control is most important for prevention extended ductile destruction of gas pipelines, that can make serious damage for economy and environment. The counterstand of running fracture extension is material property, which determine its ability of extended destruction arrest. The index of this ability is minimal absorbed energy of ductile fracture arrest, which is estimated by the results of full-sized burst tests. These tests are cumbersome and expensive enough. That is why Batelle Two Curv Method (BTCM) was proposed for definition running fracture arrest energy. In this test arrest energy is expressed by absorbed Charpy-V energy. BTCM was invented at  the beginning of 70s XX century and it was successfully used for steels with strength categories before X65, which have low or medium ductility.  After that new  high-ductile tube steels appeared in the industry, which were made with thermomechanical rolling method. It was discovered, that for this steels immediate  measurement Charpy-V energy is not reliable index of destruction arrest. That is why it was decided to determine  Charpy-V energy by the value of absorbed DWTT energy with using equalizations of correlation Charpy-V energy and DWTT energy. The range of such equalizations is already known. However, as it was shown in the analysis, all of them have crucial issues and disadvantages, which need characterization of correct and effective using these equalizations for determination running ductile fracture arrest energy with BTCM method in high-ductile tube steels, which have different strengths and thickness. Purpose. The characterization of accordance absorbed energy  Charpy-V and Drop Weight Tear Test (DWTT) correlation equalizations with real (experimental) correlation these indexes of researched high-ductile tube steels. Material and methodology. The high-ductile steels for gas pipelines, which have strength categories X80, X70,X65 and different thickness, were chosen as materials for research. Drop weight tear tests (DWTT)  were realized with using Zwick firm vertical drop machine. Full-sized samples with pressured cut were assayed in automatic registration curves force-moving mode. Full absorbed energy of destruction, energy of fracture genesis and running were determined . The quantity of ductile component in full-sized DWTT samples was estimated in accordance with standard 
APIRP5L3-96 (2007) and standard BSEN 10274:1999. Charpy-V energy was determined in accordance with standard  ГОСТ 9454-78 on the samples type H. Results. It was gotten real (experimental) correlation of absorbed Charpy-V and DWTT energy in modern high-ductile tube steels, which are extensively used in gas pipelines building. Scientific novelty. It was analysed  the modern condition of the problem with characterization destruction arrest in high-ductile  tube steels for high-pressure gas-pipelines. It was shown, that Wilkowski linear equalization for hot-rolled and normalized steels with strength categories before X65 fully accords with real correlation absorbed DWTT energy-absorbed Charpy-V energy in high-ductile steels with thickness before 25 mm, which were treated with thermomechanical rolling. If the steel has big thickness, no one of considered correlation equalizations will not accord with real correlation DWTT energy and Charpy-V energy. It is necessary to use real correlation of absorbed DWTT energy and Charpy-V energy  for high-ductile steels with such thickness or develop calculation methods to the way of  immediate using DWTT energy instead of  calculated with correlation equalizations Charpy-V energy. Practical value. It were specified the conditions of using BTCM method in accordance with half-ampirical correlation equalizations of absorbed  Charpy-V energy and DWTT energy, and real correlation of these variables during running ductile fracture arrest energy determination  in gas pipelines, that are made from modern high-ductile steels.

Author Biographies

V. S. Vakhrusheva, State Higher Education Establishment “Pridniprovsk State Academy of Civil Engineering and Architecture”

Department of Materials Science and Materials Processing, Dr. Sc. (Tech), Prof.

A. D. Luchkov, State Enterprise “Research and Dsign-technology Institute of the Tube Industry Ya.Yu. Osada by name”

Cand. Sc. (Phys.-Math.), Lead. Res. Fell.

M. V. Pushkarenko, State Higher Education Establishment “Pridniprovsk State Academy of Civil Engineering and Architecture”

Department of Materials Science and Materials Processing, Master

References

Стандарт APIRP5L3−96. Трубы магистральные. Рекомендуемый метод проведения испытаний на ударный разрыв падающим грузом. − 2007. − 98 c.

Стандарт BSEN10274:1999. Материалы с металлическими свойствами. Испытание падающим грузом. − 1999. − 87 c.

ГОСТ 30456−97 Металлопродукция. Прокат листовой и трубы стальные. Методы испытания на ударный изгиб. − 2006. − 85 c.

Halsen K. O. Drop Weight Tear Testing of a High-Toughness Linepipe. Material / K. O. Halsen, D. N. Veritas // Proceedings of IPC 2004 International Pipeline Conference (October 4−8, 2004). − Calgary, Alberta, Canada. − 2004. − Pp. 24−29.

Оценка остановки распространения разрушения в стальных трубах XI00, полученных по технологии ТМКО, для газопроводов высокого давления / [Дж. Демофонти, Дж. Маннуччи и др.] // Современные стали для газонефтепроводных труб. Проблемы и перспективы : междунар. сем. − Москва. − 2006. − 22 с.

Hwang В. Analysis of Inverse Fracture Occuring in Hammer-Impacted Region during Drop-Weight Tear Test of a High-Toughness Linepipe Steel / B. Hwang, S. Lee, Y. M. Kim, J. Nack // Proceedings of the Thirteen Int. Offshore and Polar engineering Conference. − 2003. − Pp. 34−38.

Стандарт ANS / API спецификация 5L/ISO 3183:2007. Спецификация на магистральные трубы.

Wilkowski G. Evaluation of Fracture Speed on Ductile Fracture Resistance / G. Wilkowski, D. J. Shim, F. W. Brust // International Conference on Pipeline. − Ostende, Belgium. − October 12−14, 2009. − Pp. 51−56.

Cosham A. Don't drop the drop-weight tear test / A. Cosham, D. J. Jones, R. Eiber, Dr.P. Hopkins // The Journal of Pipeline Engineering. − Vol. 9, №. 2, June 2010. − Рp. 69−85.

Zhu X.-K. Ductile-fracture arrest methods for gas – transmission pipelines using / X.-K. Zhu, B. N. Leis // Charpy impact energy or DWTT energy. − Journal of Pipeline Engineering. − Vol. 12, № 3. − 2013. − Pp. 17−23.

Maxey W. A. Ductile fracture initiation propogation and arrest in cylindrical vessels / W. A. Maxey, J. F. Kiefner, R. J. Eiber, A. R. Duffy // Fracture toughness. − ASTM STR514. − Part 2. − 1972. − Pp. 347−362.

Mannucci G. Control of Ductile Fracture Propagation in X80 Gas Linepipe / G. Mannucci, G. Demofonti // The Journal of Pipeline Engineering. − 3d Quarter, 2011. − Pp. 27−32.

Wilkowski G. M. Use ode a Brittle Notch DWTT Specimen to Predict Fracture Characteristics of Line Pipe Steels, presented at the ASME / G. M. Wilkowski, W. A. Maxey, R. J. Eiber. − 1977. − Energy Technology Conference. − Houston, Texas. − Paper 11−Pet−21. − September 18-22. − 1977. − Pp. 45−49.

Wilkowski G. Fracture propagation toughness measurements / G. Wilkowski // Proceedings of the 6th Symposium on Line Pipe Research. Paper. − Houston, USA. − 1979. − Pp. 62−69.

Wilkowski G. Effect of drade on ductile fracture arrest criteria for gas pipelines / G. Wilkowski, D. L. Rudland, H. Xu, N. Sanderson // Proceedings of the International Pipeline Conference. − Canada. − Paper IPC 006−10350. − 2006. − Pp. 62−69.

Kawaguchi S. Application of X80 in Japan : fracture control / S. Kawaguchi and oth. // Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on Pipeline Technology. − Ostand, Belgium. − 2004. − Pp. 17−20.

Makino H. Simulation method foe crack propogation and arrest of shear fracture in natural gas transmission pipelines / H. Makino, T. Inoue, T. Kubo, T. Matsumoto // Pipe Dreamer’s conference. − Yokohama Japan. − November 7−8. − 2002. − Pp. 31−35.

Makino H. Fracture arrest ability of high pressure gas transmission pipelines by sigh strength pipelines / H. Makino, I. Takeuchi, R. Higuchi // Proceedings of the Pipeline Technology Conference. − Ostend, Belgium. − 2009. − Pp. 73−77. 36. Demofonti G. Existing methods for the evaluation of material fracture resistance for high grade steel pipeline / G. Demofonti, G. Mannuchi, P. Roovers // Joint Technical Meeting. − Canberra. − 16−19th . − April, 2007. − Pp. 22−36.

Published

2019-04-14